For years, fans have been debating it. Coaches have been asked. Social media has exploded with comparisons.

But now, WNBA General Managers — the people actually making the decisions behind the scenes — are finally weighing in on the biggest question in women’s college basketball:

WNBA GM Makes Clear Choice Between Caitlin Clark, Paige Bueckers | Yardbarker

Paige Bueckers vs. Caitlin Clark — who do the pros REALLY want?

And what they’re saying?
It might surprise you.

Two Phenoms, Two Paths to Greatness

Let’s break it down:

Absolutely": 3x WNBA Champion controversially picks Paige Bueckers over Caitlin Clark as her no.1 pick

Caitlin Clark just wrapped up a historic NCAA career as the all-time leading scorer (men’s or women’s). Known for her deep-range shooting, flashy passes, and insane stat lines, she’s become the face of college basketball, period.

Paige Bueckers, meanwhile, has battled injuries but remains one of the most efficient, high-IQ, and clutch players in the game. A former National Player of the Year, she’s a pure point guard with elite decision-making and next-level court vision.

 

Both are stars.
But WNBA execs see things beyond the highlight reels.

Caitlin Clark stats vs Paige Bueckers stats: Who's the better player?

What GMs Are REALLY Saying

In a recent anonymous poll conducted by league insiders, several WNBA General Managers were asked:

“If you had the No. 1 overall pick in the 2024 or 2025 draft, and both were eligible, who would you choose — Paige Bueckers or Caitlin Clark?”

Here’s a snapshot of the responses:

Paige Bueckers stats vs. Iowa: What is the UConn Guard's record against Caitlin Clark's Hawkeyes?

“Caitlin Clark is a generational scorer. But in terms of WNBA-style basketball, Paige might be more plug-and-play. She’s more controlled. Less high-risk.”

“If you want a box office attraction, Clark is the pick. If you want a championship floor general, give me Bueckers.”

“It’s not black and white. Paige has had less wear and tear because of the time off. Clark’s minutes and usage have been off the charts. That matters in the pros.”

“Clark is a marketing dream. But Paige fits almost any system.”

Caitlin Clark vs. Paige Bueckers stats: Iowa, UConn stars shine through struggles in Final Four duel | Sporting News Canada

The Verdict? It’s Closer Than You Think

While Clark may be the bigger name right now, thanks to her record-breaking senior year and massive NIL spotlight, Bueckers is gaining ground fast as she heads into what could be her final year at UConn.

Why? Because WNBA basketball is different.
It’s:

Slower pace

More physical defense

Smaller rosters

And way less margin for error

 

Caitlin Clark vs. Paige Bueckers stats comparison: A look inside the NCAA career numbers for Iowa, UConn stars | Sporting News Canada

 

 

And that’s where Bueckers’ style — smart, efficient, low-turnover — starts to shine in the eyes of front offices.

Clark is still seen as a No. 1 pick. But Bueckers?
She’s not far behind… and for some teams, she’s already ahead.

2025 Draft: The Real Showdown

With Caitlin Clark already drafted by the Indiana Fever in 2024, all eyes are now on the 2025 WNBA Draft, where Paige Bueckers is expected to go No. 1 — if she declares.

Caitlin Clark vs. Paige Bueckers is a rematch years in the making - Chicago Sun-Times

But don’t be surprised if WNBA teams start building around Paige the same way the Fever are building around Clark.

Two different styles.
Two different personalities.


One thing in common: franchise player written all over them.

Is it safe to ask if Paige Bueckers, not Caitlin Clark, is the best player in women's college basketball? - Chicago Sun-Times

Final Word: The League Is in Good Hands

The Bueckers vs. Clark debate isn’t just about who’s “better.”
It’s about what kind of star you want.

Do you want the flamethrower who can drop 40 on any night?
Or the steady surgeon who makes everyone around her better?

 

Either way, the WNBA wins.
And fans?
We’re about to witness a new era of elite guard play — and it starts right now.