The WNBA spotlight has never shone brighter, and Angel Reese, one of the league’s most talked-about rookies, is right in the middle of it. Known for her fiery personality and tenacious rebounding, Reese has been a magnet for both praise and criticism this season. But when Stephen A. Smith, ESPN’s most outspoken analyst, weighed in on her recent performances, the debate went to another level.

Was it tough love from a veteran commentator, or did Stephen A. go too far?

Reese’s Struggles on the Court

Angel Reese entered the league with massive expectations after leading LSU to a national title and emerging as a cultural icon. But her transition to the professional level hasn’t been smooth. Through her first several games with the Chicago Sky, Reese has struggled with:

Shooting efficiency (below 35%)

Frequent foul trouble

Difficulty finishing around the rim against bigger defenders

While her rebounding numbers remain strong — consistently grabbing 8–10 boards per game — her offensive impact has been limited.

Stephen A. Smith Weighs In

On a recent episode of First Take, Stephen A. didn’t hold back:

“Listen, I love Angel Reese’s energy. I love her presence. But let’s not confuse hype with production. She’s got to show up. This is the pros now — you don’t get points for charisma.”

He continued:

“The WNBA is not just about effort; it’s about execution. I know she’s young, but she needs to elevate her game and fast — otherwise, she’s going to fall behind in a league filled with killers.”

His comments sparked immediate backlash — and support — across the sports world.

Fans Divided: Fair or Too Harsh?

The reaction online has been swift and divided.

Supporters of Stephen A. say:

“He’s not hating — he’s just holding her to the standard she asked for.”

“She’s in the WNBA now. No more college-style hype trains. It’s about results.”

Critics of his take argue:

“Why are we always harsher on young Black women athletes?”

“Stephen A. never gave male rookies this much heat this early.”

Some fans also pointed out that Reese is adjusting to a new system, faster pace, and stronger defenders — and that she deserves time to grow like any other rookie.

What Do the Numbers Say?

Angel Reese currently averages:

9.8 points per game

8.6 rebounds per game

3.1 fouls per game

37% FG shooting

These numbers show promise, especially on the boards, but also reveal areas that need improvement — particularly in efficiency and defense. For a player drafted to be a future cornerstone, the expectations are high.

Tough Love or Targeted Criticism?

Stephen A. Smith’s approach is known to be bold, but some wonder if his tone was more damaging than helpful. Is Reese being given the space to learn and adapt — or is she being prematurely judged because of her fame?

Meanwhile, Reese herself remains focused. She hasn’t directly addressed Stephen A.’s comments, but in a recent interview, she said:

“I’m learning every game. I want to be great — and greatness takes time.”

Bottom Line:

Angel Reese is young. She’s under pressure. She’s still growing.

Stephen A. Smith’s critique may be rooted in truth — but how we hold athletes accountable matters just as much as what we say.

Whether it was tough love or unfair criticism, one thing’s for sure:
The eyes of the basketball world are staying locked on Angel Reese — and her next move matters more than ever.