In a bold move that has already sparked plenty of debates, the Green Bay Packers have formally proposed a rule change to ban the controversial “tush push” play, which gained widespread attention after the Philadelphia Eagles successfully utilized it in the 2022 and 2023 NFL seasons. This play, often referred to as the “quarterback sneak,” has drawn the ire of many teams, players, and analysts, leading to growing calls for the NFL to reassess its legality.

Eagles' Tush Push viral again: What the 'brotherly shove' play is

What is the “Tush Push”?

The “tush push” is a play where the quarterback takes a direct snap and attempts to gain short yardage, typically on third or fourth down. What makes this play particularly effective—and controversial—is the additional assistance from teammates pushing the quarterback from behind, which increases the chances of converting the short-yardage situation. The Eagles, led by quarterback Jalen Hurts, have executed this play with remarkable success, making it a central part of their offensive strategy.

While the “tush push” may seem like a simple and effective way to pick up a few yards, its effectiveness and frequent use in high-stakes moments have caused a stir in the NFL community. Opposing teams argue that the play could give the Eagles an unfair advantage by essentially allowing a player to gain extra momentum with the help of teammates, thus violating the spirit of fair competition.

Eagles Super Bowl: How 'tush push' physics could give Birds an edge - WHYY

Packers’ Proposal: A Response to Growing Concerns

The Packers, along with several other teams, have expressed concerns over the growing prevalence of the “tush push” in the NFL, leading them to submit a proposal to ban the play outright. Their argument centers on safety and competitive fairness. The Packers’ proposal argues that the push from behind could lead to higher injury risks, especially with the potential for players to get trapped or pushed into awkward positions. Furthermore, they suggest that the play goes against the nature of football, where individual skill, rather than sheer force and group assistance, should determine the outcome.

The NFL’s Response

The NFL’s competition committee has stated that they are reviewing the “tush push” and other similar plays. While no official ban has been enacted as of now, the growing pressure from teams like the Packers, as well as other detractors, could lead to a rule change in the near future. League officials have noted that they will take player safety into account, along with concerns about the fairness of the play. However, they also recognize that the “tush push” has become a strategic element for some teams and that any potential rule change could have widespread implications across the league.

NFL should put a stop to the Eagles' 'tush push' play - Newsday

Support for the Tush Push

Not everyone agrees with the Packers’ stance. Many teams, including the Eagles, defend the play, arguing that it is simply a strategic use of the rules as they currently stand. Supporters point out that other teams could easily adopt the “tush push” if they wanted to, but it’s the Eagles’ execution of the play—and Hurts’ unique skill set—that has made it so successful. The play requires precise timing, good coordination, and trust in the offensive line, making it less of a “cheat code” and more of a testament to a well-executed, power-based offensive strategy.

Eagles head coach Nick Sirianni has come out in defense of the play, stating that there’s nothing illegal about the tactic. He argued that while some may not like the play, it’s within the rules of the game, and the Eagles are simply maximizing their chances in critical situations.

Should the NFL ban the Philadelphia Eagles patented Tush Push? – The  Wingspan

What’s Next?

As the NFL approaches the offseason and teams prepare for the upcoming season, it’s clear that the debate surrounding the “tush push” will continue to heat up. The Packers’ proposal to ban the play could be a significant moment in the evolution of NFL rules, and its outcome could shape the strategies used by teams for years to come.

It’s worth noting that rule changes in the NFL are typically slow and require significant support across team owners and league officials. Even if the Packers’ proposal does not result in an immediate ban, it will certainly spark further discussion about player safety, competitive balance, and the overall integrity of the game.

 

For now, teams like the Eagles will continue to take advantage of the “tush push” as long as it remains legal, and the rest of the league will be watching closely, waiting to see if the NFL decides to make a change. Regardless of the outcome, one thing is clear: the “tush push” has become one of the most talked-about plays in recent NFL history, and its future remains uncertain.